The choice at a glance
Seven steps: understand each option, weigh what it means for you, then decide.
- Understand
- Weigh
- Decide
- If you leave early The cost of leaving
What each one costs to break: the calculation is not the same.
- Your next few years Your plans
Selling, refinancing, moving: anything that could cut the term short.
The numbers to know
- of interest: the usual penalty to break a variable rate
- 3 months
- of interest or IRD, whichever is greater: the usual penalty on a fixed rate
- 3 months or IRD
- more interest in the first year if the rate rises by 1 point, on $300,000
- 3 000 $
- the most common fixed-term lengths
- 1 to 10 years
- penalty to switch lenders at maturity, whatever the type of rate
- 0 $
- available partner lenders: banks, credit unions and specialized lenders
- 20+
General rules in effect in November 2026. No current rate is quoted here: they change every week, and this guide predicts nothing.
1 The fixed rate: stability
With a fixed rate, your rate is known for the whole length of the term. Your payment doesn't move: at signing, you know what you will pay each month until maturity, whatever rates do in the meantime.
- a predictable budget, from the first payment to maturity;
- no surprises if rates rise during the term;
- a choice of term, commonly ranging from 1 to 10 years, depending on the lender.
What stability doesn't give you
If rates fall, your rate doesn't follow: you keep the one you signed. And if you have to leave the loan before the end of the term, the penalty on a fixed rate is generally the greater of 3 months' interest and the IRD — see the cost of leaving.
2 The variable rate: flexibility
A variable rate is tied to your lender's prime rate, which generally follows the Bank of Canada's policy rate. When the latter changes, yours changes shortly after: it can go down, as well as up.
- a rate that benefits from a drop, without you having to renegotiate;
- an exit penalty that is generally simpler and lower;
- with some lenders, the option of switching to a fixed rate during the term (see below).
Two ways to pay, depending on the lender
How a variable rate shows up in your payment isn't the same at every lender:
- A payment that stays the same. When the rate changes, it's the share of interest and the share of principal in each payment that shift. If rates rise, a larger share goes to interest: the balance goes down more slowly.
- A payment that adjusts. When the rate changes, your payment changes too, up or down.
Ask before you sign: which of the two applies? And what happens if the rate rises to the point where the payment no longer covers the interest? Conditions vary from one lender to another, and they are found in the contract.
3 In between: mixed and convertible
Fixed or variable isn't always an all-or-nothing choice. Depending on the lender, other options exist:
- The mixed loan. The loan is split into a fixed-rate portion and a variable-rate portion. It's a compromise: you keep stability on one part, and flexibility on the other.
- The convertible variable. Some lenders let you switch from a variable rate to a fixed rate during the term. The fixed rate offered at that time, and any fees, depend on the lender: it isn't a return to the original rate.
None of these options is better in itself. They deserve to be compared like the others: by penalty, conditions and what they imply for your budget.
4 The cost of leaving
Selling, refinancing or switching lenders before maturity means repaying the loan earlier than planned: the lender charges a penalty. It isn't the same depending on the type of rate, and it's one of the most concrete differences between the two.
- Variable rate: generally 3 months' interest — a simple calculation you can do yourself.
- Fixed rate: the greater of 3 months' interest and the IRD (interest rate differential). The IRD calculation method varies from one lender to another, and the gap between two lenders can amount to several thousand dollars.
Illustrative example: on a $300,000 balance at 4%, 3 months' interest comes to $3,000. That's the usual penalty on a variable rate at that level; for a fixed rate, it's only the floor, and the IRD can exceed it by a wide margin.
The details of the calculation, and why two lenders don't arrive at the same figure, are in the renewal guide.
Estimate your penalty → Based on your lender's method: 3 months' interest or IRD.
And at the end of the term, there is no penalty at all: changing the type of rate, or the lender, costs nothing at that point. It's the right time to revisit your choice.
5 Your room to manoeuvre
Rather than trying to work out which rate will be best — nobody knows —, measure what your budget could handle. The test is simple: imagine your rate goes up, and see whether the month still feels comfortable.
Illustrative example, on a $300,000 balance: the extra interest in the first year if the rate rises.
| Rate increase | Extra interest, 1st year |
|---|---|
| 0.5 point | $1,500 (about $125 a month) |
| 1 point | $3,000 (about $250 a month) |
| 2 points | $6,000 (about $500 a month) |
This is the order of magnitude of the interest, calculated on the starting balance; the exact effect on your payment depends on how your lender applies it (see the variable rate).
- If a rise of 1 or 2 points would put you in difficulty, the stability of a fixed rate has real value for you.
- If your budget could absorb it without stress, the flexibility of a variable rate is an option that stays open.
Compare two rates → The comparison tool calculates the payment on your balance at two rates, side by side.
6 Your plans
The type of rate depends as much on your life as on the market. The more a plan could make you leave the loan before maturity, the more the penalty matters in your choice:
- Selling or moving in the next few years;
- Refinancing for renovations or to consolidate debts;
- A change in your situation: job, family, separation, retirement;
- A large repayment planned before maturity (inheritance, sale of an asset).
If you sell in order to buy again, porting your loan may let you avoid part, or even all, of the penalty: an option to explore before deciding, whatever the type of rate.
Good to know: the term and the type of rate are two separate choices. A short fixed-rate term ends sooner, so it brings you back sooner to a point with no penalty.
7 Deciding
Four questions, in this order, generally lead to a clear answer:
- Does my budget hold up if the rate rises by 1 or 2 points? If not, a fixed rate deserves serious consideration.
- Could I leave the loan before maturity? If so, compare the cost of leaving, not just the rate.
- What happens, concretely, if the rate rises? Fixed or adjusting payment: the answer is in the lender's contract.
- How would I feel on a morning when the rate has moved? A choice that keeps you up at night isn't the right one, even if it looks better on paper.
No answer is universal: two people with the same balance and the same income can make different choices and both be right. A 15-minute call is generally enough to see what each option would look like for your file, across 20+ lenders.
Five common mistakes
- Choosing based on the gap between the two rates at the time, without testing a rise. The gap changes; your budget, on the other hand, has to hold up in every case.
- Believing the fixed rate is “risk-free”. It protects your payment, not your exit: the IRD can amount to several thousand dollars.
- Relying on a forecast — from a relative, an article, a news bulletin. Nobody knows the next move in rates.
- Forgetting your plans. Selling or refinancing mid-term changes the calculation.
- Comparing the rate without comparing the penalty and the conditions. Two lenders at the same rate can cost very differently on exit.
Stéphanie Weyman, mortgage broker at Hypotheca, AMF certificate no. 255885. Based in Repentigny, she works with homeowners across Quebec, by Teams, phone or text.
Fixed or variable: and for you?
Every file is different. In 15 minutes, we look at your budget, your plans and what each option would look like with the lenders that suit your situation.
This guide presents general rules in effect in November 2026. They may change, and your situation may call for other solutions: it does not replace advice tailored to your file. The figures are illustrative and are neither a rate forecast nor a promise. Rates, conditions and financing approval are the lender's responsibility.